Showing posts with label defense industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defense industry. Show all posts

Friday, October 19, 2007

More Creative Class Hoo-Hah

Richard Florida is a hot topic in Dayton.

He must have impressed some movers and shakers as there is a move afoot to retain his consultancy to do some sort of creative class study of the Dayton economy.

The Dayton Daily News even has two articles on this:

Creative Dayton, Will it Work Here?

Dayton area has ingredients for creative class, says task force group.

There is some transparent spin in the article:

For example, from the articles:

"One of the area's major assets, the task force realized, is its high concentration of a diverse group of colleges and universities, which in 2005 contributed nearly $3 billion to the local economy."

What high concentration? UD and WSU and Sinclair? Or are they counting Central State, Wlberforce, Wittenberg and Cedarville College, too? This is laughable, or transparent boosterism.

Then there are some half-truths:

But another study published in August in the Journal of Economic Geography tested the creative class theory and found that results supported the idea that a creative milieu attracting artists "increases an area's economic dynamism."

...and here is that study: Emoting with their feet: Bohemian attraction to creative mileu.

The study focuses to some extent on rural areas as the authors work with rural/ag economics. The article also considers urban areas. From the conclusion:

Moving beyond the attraction of creative workers, our strong definition of creative milieu is more germane to the policy debate animated by discussion of the creative class. For metro areas, our findings are unsatisfying as they identify a potentially large effect, but one that fails to meet conventional standards of reliability.

Given the point estimate, metro counties in the top decile of creative milieu would generate close to twice the number of new establishments per worker compared to metro counties in the bottom decile. This is confirmed in the sample, where the top decile generated three establishments per hundred workers, on average, compared to 1.6 establishments generated in the bottom decile.
Unfortunately, the standard error associated with the point estimate is large. The prudent conclusion is to suspend judgment on the existence of a strong creative milieu in metro areas.

Personally, I think Florida is correct to some extent, but also that should take care in specific cases as his is a generalized theory. Dayton could well be a special case.

As one can see by the extensive look at the local economy elsewhere on this blog, the Dayton area is doing quite well in things like computer services, engineering, consulting, "information", and, in Greene County, Scientific R&D. The driver for much of this is probably defense spending. This military-oriented mileu, with its security clearances, classified programs, and cultural conservatism, is not what one thinks of when thinks of Richard Florida's emphaisis on "bohemianism".

The Dayton area is already attracting elements of the creative class, but more on the techie/military side, not the arty/bohemian side.